Christmas Without Hanukkah?

In a letter to the editor in the Times News Online in Lehighton, Pa on December 29th, 2012, Pastor Marie Terry stated that “Christmas would be impossible without Hanukkah” [i]. After briefly recounting the events that brought about the festival of Hanukkah, she explained,

“Two miracles plus a common theme link Hanukkah and Christmas in a way I hope will heighten your appreciation of both.The first miracle is the preservation of the Jewish people. Had Antiochus been successful, Israel would have lost her unique identity and God’s precious promise would be unkept. If Antiochus had gotten his way, there would have been no recognizable Jewish culture for the Messiah to be born into. Without Hanukkah, there would have been no Christmas” [ii].

Pastor Terry is not the first to make this observation; multiple Christian pastors, teachers, and commentators have made the same assertion over the years. The concern that niggles at my thoughts, however, is simply, who is in control of history, the Creator or his creation? Is man able to so confound the plans of HaShem that he has to find another way to accomplish his plans? It seems not. Way back in Genesis 11, we read about mankind deciding not to populate the whole earth, but instead they, as one, decided to build an edifice for themselves. HaShem apparently did not go along with their plans. He confounded their language so that they had no choice but to spread out to different areas of the globe. Ultimately the edifice they built to themselves fell to the ravages of time.

Thinking back to Antiochus and the destruction of Jewish culture and society, I believe HaShem had already settled that issue when he spoke through the prophet Jeremiah,

“Thus says Adonai, who gives the sun as a light by day and the fixed order of the moon and the stars as a light by night, who stirs up the sea so its waves roar, Adonai-Tzva’ot is His Name: “Only if this fixed order departs from before Me”—it is a declaration of Adonai—“then also might Israel’s offspring cease from being a nation before Me—for all time” (Jeremiah 31:34-35) [iii].

These words from the prophet are fortified by the words of King David:

“Adonai foils the purpose of the nations. He thwarts the plans of the peoples. The plan of Adonai stands forever, the purposes of His heart from generation to generation.” (Psalm 33:10-11)

Or maybe as the Yiddish proverb states, Der mentsh trakht un got lakht, Man plans, and God laughs.

Israel’s existence and continuance as a people was and never will be contingent upon the whims of a dictator or a demigod with delusions of grandeur or world domination. Israel was, is, and forever will be, HaShem’s am segula, treasured people. Plus, he is more than able to take care of and watch over Israel just as the psalmist wrote,

“Behold, the Keeper of Israel neither slumbers nor sleeps. Adonai is your Keeper. Adonai is your shadow at your right hand.” (Psalm 121:4-5)

So, whether Israel’s deliverance comes through Moshe and Aaron proclaiming the Ten Plagues against Pharaoh or a small band of warrior priests who exercised guerrilla warfare against the mighty Antiochus IV, HaShem is watching over Israel. It is the authority and power of HaShem that brings about the victory. As we light the Hanukkah candles this year, we once again remember that

“The light of our faith burns brightly now; our people Israel has survived all who sought to destroy us. In every generation, we are called, in true love and self-sacrifice, to renew ourselves and the life of our people” [iv].

Hanukkah Sameach, Happy Hanukkah!

This article was written by Rabbi Michael Hillel. For more by Rabbi Hillel, read his articles “Stay Focused on the Goal,” “A Time for Rain,” or “A Time for Rejoicing.”


[i] https://www.tnonline.com/20121229/christmas-impossible-without-hanukkah/

[ii] The second miracle is that of the cruse of oil which was adequate for one day and lasted for eight.

[iii] Unless otherwise noted, Scriptures are from the Tree of Life (TLV) translation of the Bible. Copyright © 2015 by The Messianic Jewish Family Bible Society.

[iv] Introduction to Judaism, A Source Book, compiled and edited by Stephen J. Einstein & Lydia Kukoff, NewYork, UAHC Press, 1998, p27

Explore our blog:

The Light of the World

How do the similarities between Hanukkah and Christmas reflect on the relationship between Jews and Christians in this most festive season?

Christmas Without Hanukkah?

If you think about it, Christmas wouldn’t exist without Hanukkah. What does that say about God’s plan for Israel and for history?

Hanukkah Stories

Rabbi Dr. Vered Hillel has compiled a few of her favorite children’s Hanukkah stories to read each night—with accompanying videos!

Hanukkah: Celebrating the Light of Messiah

Hanukkah celebrates the miracle of the oil, where a day’s worth of oil lasted eight days. But how historically plausible is this narrative?

Hanukkah in Israel

Rabbi Dr. Vered Hillel reminisces on past Hanukkah celebrations in Israel and all their associated traditions.

Hanukkah 5781

Rabbi Michael Hillel discusses the significance of the brachot (blessings) we say during Hanukkah, and what that can tell us about the holiday.

2020 Board of Directors Update

This year, MJTI’s annual Board of Directors meeting was held online for the first time. This news release shares the fruits of that meeting.

Gilgamesh, the Flood, and the Garden

R. Klayman takes a look at the Epic of Gilgamesh and finds an overlooked parallel: Gilgamesh’s plant of immortality and the Garden of Eden.

Life’s Path

Rabbi Rich Nichol shares a few more nuggets of wisdom while surrounded by the beauty of the Northeastern autumn.

Stay Focused on the Goal

Pressing on when you feel spiritually exhausted can feel impossible. R. Hillel shares an inspiring perspective on this week’s parasha.

Pin It on Pinterest